IR market projections may be too rosy

While many industry analysts continue to assume that either Tokyo or Yokohama will pursue an IR bid, the political realities of Japanese local communities seem to indicate otherwise.

In the case of Tokyo, it’s entirely unclear why analysts should believe there’s a serious possibility that it will seek an IR at this time. The metropolitan government’s administrative bandwidth is already absorbed by preparations for the 2020 Olympics. The potential sites for an IR are earmarked for other Olympics-related construction. Politically, too, there’s no reason to believe that Governor Yuriko Koike desires the kind of political fight that it would take to propel a strikingly unpopular casino initiative.

Yokohama is far more plausible. Mayor Fumiko Hayashi had earlier embraced an IR initiative and the city has conducted various studies. Elements of the business community are strongly in favor, though the local opposition is also quite robust. Mayor Hayashi says she hasn’t made any decision yet, and she may indeed decide that the prize isn’t worth the struggle. At any rate, there’s no reason to automatically assume that there will be a Yokohama bid.

If so, estimates of market size such as Morgan Stanley’s released on April 11 will likely prove to be too rosy.

The Morgan Stanley report projects a Tokyo-area IR of US$6 billion in scale, Osaka with US$4 billion, and a third city with US$2.5 billion market. Together with leakage of about US$2.5 billion, they see a US$15 billion Japanese IR market developing by 2025.

This projection, however, effectively depends upon Yokohama Mayor Fumiko Hayashi making a policy decision that it is by no means certain that she will make.

Otherwise, it will likely be the Osaka IR alone as the only major urban market facility in Japan, with two regional areas—perhaps Tomakomai and Nagasaki the leading candidates—building smaller IRs in the first round of development.

If Morgan Stanley’s other projections are correct, that would suggest a Japanese IR market in the US$10 billion range.

Previous articleBeijing nods development of horse racing, sports lottery in Hainan
Next articleGenting seeks mandate for remaining NCLH sale

Related Articles

Hayashi IR

Yokohama mayor gives first nod to democracy

Yokohama Mayor Fumiko Hayashi has, for the very first time, acknowledged that the people of her city might actually have a voice in whether or not to build a major IR along the coastline.

Yokohama mayor says she would respect IR referendum result

Yokohama Mayor Fumiko Hayashi stated for the first time that should the city be forced to hold a referendum on IR development and lose the vote, she would respect the people’s decision and withdraw the city’s candidacy.

Japan IRs have a new schedule

After spending most of this year in denial or else paralyzed by the crisis of the Covid-19 pandemic, the Japanese central government has finally made a credible decision about its IR development plans, which is to push back the timeline by nine months.

Yokohama seeks dialogue with operators on impact of pandemic

Recognizing that the Covid-19 pandemic may have exercised an important impact on IR development, Yokohama Mayor Fumiko Hayashi has indicated that her municipal administration would seek a dialogue on this issue with interested IR operators. “The revitalization of tourism and the MICE industry is indispensable for the long-term advance of Yokohama’s economy,” Hayashi declared, “but […]

Yokohama anti-casino signature drives preparing to launch

The two major citizen group efforts to head off IR development plans in Yokohama are preparing to launch their signature drives, keeping the political pressure on even as national policy has stalled. Launching first, from September 4 until November 4, is the petition demanding a popular referendum over the city’s IR development plans. The aim […]

Yokohama mayor indefinitely delays IR development plans

Yokohama Mayor Fumiko Hayashi stated at a press conference that her city would not be issuing its local IR implementation policy this month, as planned, and that the delay would be indefinite until the central government revealed its own directions. Hayashi did indicate, however, that her firm intention to build a major IR at Yamashita […]

October start for signature drive to recall pro-IR Yokohama mayor

A citizens group opposing the development of the Yokohama IR has affirmed that its signature drive to trigger a recall vote against Mayor Fumiko Hayashi will kick off in October. The organizers need to gather about 500,000 signatures in a two month period from the city’s population of about 3,760,000 people, regarded as a high […]

Yokohama mayor: local IR plans must wait on central government policy

Yokohama Mayor Fumiko Hayashi has acknowledged that her city’s implementation policies, originally scheduled for publication in June, must wait until after the central government finally issues its long overdue IR Basic Plan. She added that any prospect that her city could publish its implementation policies by the end of August had now dried up. “We […]

Yokohama mayor supports current IR development schedule

Although she regards the January to July 2021 application window for IR licensing to be “pretty strict,” Yokohama Mayor Fumiko Hayashi made clear that her municipality would not be requesting any policy change from the central government. “It’s not a good thing for the national schedule to change,” she remarked, “We are not requesting any […]

Public opposition to Yokohama IR appears to intensify

It has often been suggested that Japanese local communities will become more understanding of IR development projects once their nature is better explained, but public opinion polling in the city of Yokohama seems to be showing the opposite trend. According to exit polls at the time of the July 2017 mayoral elections, three years ago, […]